This Bradford Exchange Canada ring review shares my real experience with a Toronto Blue Jays fan ring, including quality issues and customer service details.
Last fall, I began seeing ads for a Toronto Blue Jays fan ring. It was presented as a beautiful, keepsake-style piece of team jewelry. Something meaningful for a fan, not just a novelty accessory. The ads seemed to become especially prominent around October during the World Series, and the ring looked polished, well-crafted, and gift-worthy.
My sister ordered it for me in November 2025 as a Christmas gift. We were told there were multiple delays, which honestly wasn’t a huge deal…I was just happy knowing it would arrive and I would have it for the upcoming baseball season.
The ring finally showed up during the week of January 18, 2026.
When the box was opened, the difference between expectation and reality was obvious right away.
The ring that was advertised can be found HERE
The product page shows a crisp, symmetrical, professionally finished piece. The Toronto Blue Jays logo appears clean and centered, and the overall presentation suggests a premium collectible, especially at the price point.
After tax and shipping, the total came to $166 CAD.
That price sets certain expectations.
At first glance, parts of the ring looked fine. The band, stones, and general structure had potential. But the centerpiece the Blue Jays logo itself is where everything went wrong.
The logo on the ring I received was:
-
Very small
-
Noticeably crooked
-
Clearly pixelated
Instead of looking like a crisp, finished enamel or inlay design, the logo looked low-resolution and blurry around the edges. It honestly resembled a tiny printed image placed under a surface, not a carefully crafted jewelry detail.
Because the logo is the focal point of the ring, the misalignment and pixelation are impossible to ignore. It completely changed how the ring looked and felt. Rather than a premium fan collectible, it gave off a “gumball machine” or “home printer” impression.
This isn’t about being picky. It’s about visible quality issues in the main feature of the product.
Contacting Customer Service
I took the time to write what I felt was a thoughtful, honest email explaining the concerns – specifically mentioning the pixelated logo and crooked alignment.
The response I received felt very generic and impersonal, like an automated or AI-generated reply. It did not directly address the specific quality issues I described.
Instead, I received a prepaid return label in a separate email and instructions to send the ring back for a replacement. I was told the replacement process could take up to 30 days after they receive the return.
To be clear: I do want the replacement. The ring itself has the potential to be nice: the stones and overall design are appealing. I simply want the logo, which is the entire reason for the ring, to match the quality shown in the advertising.
• • • •
I’m not writing this to be dramatic or to attack a company. I’m sharing my experience so other fans know that what’s shown in advertising doesn’t always match what arrives in the box. If you’re ordering collectible jewelry online, especially licensed fan pieces at a premium price, it’s worth:
• Inspecting the item closely as soon as it arrives
• Taking clear photos right away
• Speaking up if something doesn’t look right
When a product is marketed as a special keepsake, the details matter. And when the central design element is blurry and off-center, that’s not a minor issue.. it’s the entire product. I’m hopeful the replacement will be better. But in the meantime, I think buyers deserve to know exactly what my experience looked like. 💙⚾